Blank Rome: Widespread Implications

September 19, 2023

Dennis Ehling and Gregory Bailey of Blank Rome discuss the ruling for the Seminole Tribe's exclusive online sports betting rights in Florida.

On June 30, 2023, the District of Columbia Court of Appeals issued a ruling in West Flagler Associates, Ltd. v. Haaland, allowing the Seminole Tribe to offer sports wagering in Florida. The decision upholds the 2021 Gaming Compact signed by both the Seminole Tribe and state Governor.

The DC Circuit did not rule the Compact legal under Florida law, or authorize online play outside of Seminole land, but instead opined that the Compact could authorize sports betting and online play on reservation land.

The Compact - that deemed bets placed online from anywhere in Florida to take place on Seminole land - allows the state and Tribe to avoid violating Florida’s constitutional limitations on gambling expansion.

As such, the state and Tribe slipped statewide authorization for online sports betting into an existing exception in Florida’s constitution for gaming on Tribal lands, approved under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA). However, IGRA neither creates nor governs any authorization of gambling outside Seminole land. The DC Circuit held that questions on gaming outside the reservation are best suited for Florida state courts.

Effect of the Compact

The Compact specifies that wagers placed within Florida must use the Seminoles’ computer servers. The DC Circuit held that any activity occurring outside of Indian lands is not within IGRA’s scope. This view is consistent with Michigan v. Bay Mills Indian Community, 572 U.S. 782 (2014) where the Court found that the IGRA cannot authorize or regulate gaming outside of Indian lands. As clearly stated by the Supreme Court in Bay Mills, IGRA’s overall scope is limited to “Indian lands and nowhere else.”

The DC Circuit noted that the Compact deemed wagers outside of Tribal land to still be made where the server is located. The court held that Secretary of the Interior, Debra Haaland’s, approval of the Compact did not provide an imprimatur to any gaming activity occurring outside Tribal land.

The DC Circuit concluded that the “nowhere else” scope of IGRA means IGRA neither authorizes, nor restricts, what Tribes do off reservation land. To the DC Circuit, any gaming outside Indian lands directly relates to the activity authorized by a compact and thus appropriately falls within the scope of IGRA provision 25 U.S.C. § 2710(d)(3)(vii).

The DC Circuit concluded Haaland’s allowance of the Compact does not “approve” anything occurring off-Tribal lands. Rather, the Secretary simply won't intervene to prevent the terms of the Compact discussing activity outside the reservation.

Litigation in Florida Courts?

The DC Circuit put questions to Florida state courts, including whether the legislature or Governor could legally authorize the Seminoles to accept wagers placed by Floridians outside the reservation. In 2018, the Voter Approval of Casino Gambling Initiative passed, which amended the state constitution to require a ballot initiative to authorize expansion of certain gaming operations, unless the gaming occurs on Tribal land as approved by IGRA (Fla. Const. Art. X, § 30(c).

Existing Florida law already provides that Class III gaming activities “authorized under this subsection and conducted pursuant to a gaming compact ratified and approved under subsection (3) do not violate the laws of this state.” (F.S. XIX § 285.710(13)(b).

Retail casinos opposing the Compact filed a petition for rehearing en banc by the full DC Circuit. Petitioners argue the Compact’s effective permitting wagers off-reservation land was “an abuse of IGRA to bypass a state constitutional requirement.” Federal approval of the Compact, petitioners assert, could be claimed as proof that the Fla. Const. Art. X, § 30(c) had been satisfied, even though the Secretary could not approve gaming off reservation lands.

Petitioners argue further that Bay Mills’ “nowhere else” language limits what the Secretary can approve and the DC Circuit ruling departs from precedent: If the petition for rehearing is not granted, petitioners could appeal to the United States Supreme Court. It seems clear this matter could end in Florida’s state courts.

In the meantime, the DC Circuit’s opinion clears the Seminole Tribe’s path to offer sports wagering throughout Florida, based on the legal presumption that online sports wagering occurs “exclusively” where the server processing the bet is located – on Seminole lands.


Product Spotlight


Things get unruly in the company of some fleecy characters in the new Konami Gaming’s new Unwooly Riches slot series.

John Connelly - Interblock preparing to launch online by the end of year

John Connelly, the Global CEO of Interblock, joins the Huddle to talk about:
- The company's conversion to the online space
- The performance of ETGs
- Interblock's new philanthropic efforts
- The trend of companies going private
- And more!

Michael Hershman - Dispelling casino 'myths:' New York needs to lose fear of the unknown

Michael Hershman, CEO of the Soloviev Group, joins Tim Poole on the Huddle to put forward his case that the Freedom Plaza is the way to go for one of New York's casino licences. He fields a variety of questions - not shying away from any of them - on why 'myths' about casinos and a fear of the unknown should be dispelled, as well as acknowledging the strength of rival bids and discussing opposition to the project.

Five years ago, before the mass proliferation of social media we see today – and even before the Covid-19 pandemic – I think you would be hard pressed to find a CEO talking about “Instagrammable moments.” KPIs w...

The Global Gaming Awards: Looking ahead to 2024's ceremonies.
After more than a decade of celebrating gaming's best, Gaming America looks ahead to a bright 2024 for the Global Gaming Awards in the Americas and Asia-Pacific.
From the top: The Indian Gaming Tradeshow & Convention
Tribal gaming is a uniquely American institution and all its uncommon attributes were on display this April at the Indian Gaming Tradeshow & Convention in Anaheim, California.
Review: Terre Haute Casino Resort and Harrah's Hoosier Park Racing & Casino
Terre Haute Casino Resort vs. Harrah's Hoosier Park Racing & Casino, Gaming America's Laura Mack reviews each property.
Eureka Casino interview: CEO Andre Carrier on resort expansion
We spoke with returning guest, CEO Andre Carrier, about Eureka Casino Resort's expansion. He aims to not only change the look and feel of the casino, but to also build residential housing around it.