PrizePicks Resumes Peer-to-Peer Fantasy Games in New York After Settlement
PrizePicks has relaunched peer-to-peer fantasy contests in New York following a $15 million settlement and regulatory approval.
Daily fantasy sports operator PrizePicks has resumed offering peer-to-peer fantasy contests in New York, marking a return to one of the largest fantasy sports markets in the U.S. after a regulatory dispute and financial settlement with state authorities.
The relaunch follows a $15 million settlement with the New York State Gaming Commission, which resolved allegations that PrizePicks previously offered fantasy products that did not comply with New York law.
PrizePicks confirmed that only peer-to-peer fantasy contests, not player-versus-house formats, are now available to New York residents.
In October of 2025, the NYSGC awarded PrizePicks with an interactive fantasy sports license.
What Changed: From Player-Versus-House to Peer-to-Peer
PrizePicks had previously suspended operations in New York after regulators raised concerns that some of its offerings resembled sports betting rather than permissible fantasy sports contests.
Under the relaunch:
- Players now compete against other players, not the operator
- PrizePicks no longer acts as the counterparty
- Contest outcomes are determined by comparative player performance
- Games align with New York’s fantasy sports statutory framework
This structure mirrors traditional daily fantasy sports contests long permitted in the state.
Details of the $15 Million Settlement
The settlement, finalized earlier this year, resolved claims that PrizePicks operated unapproved fantasy formats in New York.
Key components of the agreement include:
- A $15 million payment to the state
- Commitment to offer only authorized fantasy contest formats
- Ongoing compliance and reporting obligations
- Regulatory oversight by the Gaming Commission
The settlement allows PrizePicks to re-enter the market without admitting wrongdoing, while establishing clearer operational boundaries going forward.
Why New York Matters
New York is one of the most important fantasy sports markets in the country due to:
- Its large population
- High sports engagement
- Long-standing DFS player base
For operators, access to New York can materially impact user growth and revenue, making regulatory clarity especially valuable.
PrizePicks’ return also highlights how aggressively New York enforces distinctions between:
- Fantasy sports
- Sports betting
- Player prop-style games
Broader Regulatory Context
New York regulators have taken a firm stance in recent years on fantasy and betting products that blur legal lines.
The state has:
- Required strict adherence to fantasy sports definitions
- Challenged player-versus-house formats
- Pursued enforcement actions against non-compliant operators
PrizePicks’ relaunch reflects a growing pattern of companies modifying products rather than exiting the market entirely when faced with regulatory pressure.
What New York Players Can Expect
With the relaunch, New York users can:
- Enter peer-to-peer fantasy contests
- Compete against other players for pooled prizes
- Access contests across major professional sports
However, players will not have access to:
- Player-vs-house pick’em formats
- Betting-style multipliers
- Fixed-odds outcomes
PrizePicks has emphasized that its New York offerings are now tailored specifically to comply with state law.
Industry Implications
PrizePicks’ return may serve as a roadmap for other fantasy and pick’em operators navigating regulatory scrutiny.
The case demonstrates that:
- Regulators are willing to allow re-entry after compliance
- Settlements can lead to product redesign rather than market exit
- States remain highly protective of legal distinctions
As fantasy sports continue to evolve, operators are increasingly forced to tailor offerings on a state-by-state basis.
What Comes Next
PrizePicks will operate in New York under continued regulatory supervision, with any future product changes subject to review by the Gaming Commission.
Other states are watching closely, particularly those evaluating how to regulate hybrid fantasy and betting-style games.
For now, PrizePicks’ relaunch signals a reset, not a rollback, of its New York strategy.
Tags/Keywords
Players trust our reporting due to our commitment to unbiased and professional evaluations of the iGaming sector. We track hundreds of platforms and industry updates daily to ensure our news feed and leaderboards reflect the most recent market shifts. With nearly two decades of experience within iGaming, our team provides a wealth of expert knowledge. This long-standing expertise enables us to deliver thorough, reliable news and guidance to our readers.
Latest News
